Yet, study of how they form has had an erratic history. Biological species concept, we equate speciation to the evolution. The likelihood of sympatric speciation is perhaps the most controversial aspect of speciation, and certainly one of the most contested questions in evolutionary biology. If the trend holds true in these groups, it is hard to imagine any way to rede. Another rule of speciation is that genes affecting reproductive isolation are typically found on the x chromosome where x is the female chromosome. Coyne and orr do show their biases and the book does have a heavy drosophila melanogaster focus, but that is actually quite refreshing, because they dont often obscure other points of view. Jerry coyne and allen orrs book is the first major summary of the data and ideas on speciation since animal species and evolution, ernst mayrs highly influential book published in 1963.
The critical acclaim for coyne and orrs speciation is, in my view, fully warranted. Coyne and orr have done the field a great service by providing such a clear analysis of the status quo. Coyne dept of ecology and evolution, university of chicago, 1101 e. Allen orr over the last two decades, the study of speciation has expanded from a modest backwater of evolutionary biology into a large and vigorous discipline. Speciation by selection 383 natural selection 385 sexual selection 386 mathematical theories of selectionbased speciation 387 speciation by drift 387 peak shift models 388 theoretical criticisms 394 recent peak shift models 396 the data 398 evidence from the laboratory 398 evidence from nature 401 conclusions 410 11 selection versus drift 383. Theory and speciation darwinian sciences cluster university of. Jan 20, 2010 coyne and orr s method for estimating total reproductive isolation and the contribution of individual barriers has been adopted in only a few studies of speciation ramsey et al. Sep 22, 2004 speciation, a joyous duet by two of the fields leading soloists, jerry coyne and allen orr, should help.
Ecological niche dimensionality and the evolutionary diversification of stick insects. The ones marked may be different from the article in the profile. Ecological niche dimensionality and the evolutionary diversification of stick insects authors. Called the mystery of mysteries by darwin, speciation is still a littleunderstood area of evolution. Perhaps it doesnt matter for the progress of science what. Three aspects of speciation make it unique and valuable. We note only that the recent burst of work on speciation re.
The concept of a ring species is associated with allopatric speciation as a special case. Coyne s his concentration is speciation and ecological and evolutionary genetics, particularly as they involve drosophila his work is widely published, not only in scientific journals, but also in such mainstream venues as the new york times, the times literary supplement, and the new republic. Jun 30, 2004 speciation is designed to provide a unified, critical and uptodate overview of the field. This treasure trove of knowledge, which provides ample food for thought, succinctly. Jan 01, 2005 jerry coyne and allen orr s book is the first major summary of the data and ideas on speciation since animal species and evolution, ernst mayrs highly influential book published in 1963. He is currently a professor emeritus at the university of chicago in the department of ecology and evolution. Two rules of speciation, in speciation and its consequences, 1989, d. The genetic basis of evolution, adaptation and speciation. Coyne and orr in speciation categorise these forms into three groups. Jun 30, 2004 coyne and orr s speciation has been eagerly awaited. Avise, perspectives in biology and medicine coyne and orr s speciation has been eagerly awaited. Speciation integrative and comparative biology oxford.
If its messages are heeded, it will bring muchneeded order and rigor to the current burst of activity. By contrast, other models have emphasized the role of nonadaptive processes in speciation e. Speciation in general is defined as the evolution of strong, genetically based isolating barriers between. Coyne and orr s speciation has been eagerly awaited. Genetic analysis, however, has yielded new generalizations about speciation and suggests. This treasure trove of knowledge, which provides ample food. Since then, the study of speciation has grown increasingly respectable, recruiting ever more experimentalists and theorists. Examples include certain models of speciation by sexual selection e. To investigate the time course of speciation, we gathered literature data on 119. Adopting the biological species concept, we equate speciation to the evolution of reproductive isolating. The evolutionary genetics of speciation darwinian sciences cluster. What do we need to know about speciation trends in. Aimed at professional biologists, graduate students, and advanced undergraduates, speciation covers both plants and animals the first book on this subject to do so, and deals with all relevant areas of research, including biogeography, field work, systematics, theory, and genetic and molecular studies.
Aimed at professional biologists, graduate students, and advanced undergraduates, speciation covers both plants and animals the first book on this subject to do so, and deals with all relevant areas of research, including biogeography, field work, systematics, theory, and genetic and. Avise, perspectives in biology and medicine coyne and orrs speciation has been eagerly awaited. It is also criticalforourdiscussionhere,andsoweexpandonitbelow. Allen orr sinauer associates is an imprint of oxford university press aimed at professional biologists, graduate students, and advanced undergraduates, speciation covers both plants and animals the first book on this subject to do so, and deals with all relevant areas of research, including biogeography, field work, systematics, theory, and genetic and molecular studies. Allen orr university of rochester sinauer associates,inc. I discuss each of these coyne and orr views in turn. The only study comparing the rates of evolution of di. Coyne and orrs speciation has been eagerly awaited. However, the authors do develop detailed arguments against the newer work in an attempt to shore up the dobzhanskymayr tradition. Central questions about speciation such as the relative importance of geographic isolation, ecological divergence and sexual selection can be answered by accumulating case studies and. They contend that ring species provide evidence of parapatric speciation in a nonconventional sense. Speciation is designed to provide a unified, critical and uptodate overview of the field. A wonderful, indepth, and interesting summary of the field of speciation research.
Mercifully, coyne and orr relegate the semantics and substance of species concepts to a concise appendix, where a newcomer to the field might wish to begin reading. A twoallele effect requires divergence in allele frequency between populations at one or more loci or divergence in a trait servedio 2000. Short communication pattern, process and geographic. In fact, every recent study on the genetics of speciation is an analysis of reproductive isolation. A prolific scientist and author, he has published numerous papers elucidating the theory of evolution. Speciation, a joyous duet by two of the fields leading soloists, jerry coyne and allen orr, should help. The last decade has brought renewed interest in the. Although several books have appeared in the interim, none has been as broad as coyne and orr s. This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar. Jerry coyne and allen orr take center ring with speciation, and give a performance that will earn their book a place on your shelf alongside the classic tomes of their predecessors. The field of speciation research was in need of a sagacious update, and this benchmark work will provide a solid foundation for further scientific inquiry into what has been one of evolutions most engaging and enduring mysteries.
However, some of the traditional organising principles of the subject area no longer provide a satisfactory framework, such as the classification of speciation mechanisms by geographical context into allopatric, parapatric and sympatry classes. Despite the title of his book, darwin gave the process of speciation little attention in the. Short communication pattern, process and geographic modes of. Jerry allen coyne born december 30, 1949 is an american biologist known for his work on speciation and his commentary on intelligent design. We can test the pre diction that haldanes rule represents an early stage of speciation by examining ge netic distances between species whose crosses yield sterility or inviability in males only. Coyne and orr begin by showing that species are real biological units, recognised in essentially the same way by diverse cultures. Over the last two decades, the study of speciation has expanded from a modest backwater of evolutionary biology into a large and vigorous discipline. Unlike its 20th century antecedents, and in spite of the drosophila centric background of the authors, speciation is not taxonlimited. Aimed at professional biologists, graduate students, and advanced undergraduates, speciation covers both plants and animals the first book on this subject to do so, and deals with all relevant areas of research, including biogeography, field work, systematics, theory, and.
This has been the classic problem of sympatric speciation coyne and orr 2004, p. The biological species concept popularized by dobzhansky 1937 and mayr 1942 equates the origin of species with the evolution of reproductive isolation cf. Sinauer associates is an imprint of oxford university press. Systematic and incisive analysis is what makes the book so powerful. Coyne 1992a, 1993a, 1994 and will not repeat our contentions here. The biology of speciation sobel 2010 evolution wiley. This is due in part to questions about its validity. Although several books have appeared in the interim, none has been as. Nonecological speciation also includes models in which selection is involved, but is nonecological andor is not divergent between environments. Consisting of 545 closely packed pages, it contains an uptodate and very.
975 1576 1213 296 1520 256 585 1619 1156 121 1281 406 201 1171 1056 1163 378 797 1411 377 1530 1072 275 90 1332 1464 984 1309 603 51 239 760 797 820 137 1060 316 758 400 1199 441 927 610 360